• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Lobster Cay

Private Island Retreat in the Bahamas

  • Home
  • Accommodations
  • Amenities
  • Services
  • Infrastructure
  • Getting To Lobster
  • Rates/Availability
  • Contact

Looking for privacy and an intimate location for your family or friends?

Rates / Availability

Private Island Retreat in the Bahamas

Accommodations

There are four lodging facilities. Check them out and discuss with us to determine which one is best for you. Vista House Four bedrooms (3…

Amenities

Privacy will be yours, but we have a variety of unique amenities that will enhance your stay and the solid infrastructure to give you peace…

Services

Sal and Lisa are your Host and Hostess. Henrich Curry (full time caretaker) is also on site. We will respect your privacy but will be…

Infrastructure

As you consider staying at a private island, you need to make sure the facility has the infrastructure and is maintained to support your needs…

Getting To Lobster

Location We are located in Northern Eleuthera/Spanish Wells, 3 miles from The Bluff and Current and six miles from Spanish Wells/Russel Island/Royal Island. Commercial Airlines…

Rates/Availability

For only a few weeks a year, we are sharing our retirement/vacation home at a reasonable price to those who do not mind that the…

Notes from your Host and Hostess

We will be available to help you get acquainted with the workings of the Cay and to assist you as needed. We will give you the privacy you seek but be available to assist you as needed. You will have the privacy you want, but will not be abandoned. We want you to have a fantastic experience. Just communicate your needs and we will do our best to fulfill them.

–

Lobster Cay has everything you need to just get away, relax and enjoy each other. No other groups….just yours. Plenty to do, or nothing to do.  No biting insects, so enjoy the outdoors any time of day. Arrange your food and drinking requirements with us ahead of time and we will have it all ready for your arrival. You never have to leave Lobster Cay. But if you need to, it is easily arranged.

–

Lobster Cay is a truly unique private island. We only rent to one group at a time (2 – 6). Big enough with a variety of amenities. Everything you need is there. Arrange your food and drinks with us ahead of time and you never have to leave the island. If needed, trips to Spanish Wells or Mainland Eleuthera can be arranged. But why leave? Just sit back and enjoy the privacy, facilities, sun and breeze at a reasonable price compared to other Private Islands.

–

A Unique Private Island Family Retreat

No biting insects, enjoy outdoor and indoor facilities any time of day or night.

Rates / Availability

Footer

Lobster Cay is a Private Island Retreat exclusively for one group of family or friends (2 – 6) at a reasonable price.  We are opening it up for only a few weeks a year.

Lobster Island (Cay)
North Eleuthera
Bahamas

sal@wanamakerarms.com

Wanamaker Management Systems LLC
610-389-4830

    • Rss Feed
    • Facebook

  • Email

Privacy, no biting insects, 3 mile underwater power line from mainland, backup generator, boat transportation, gorgeous vistas, starlink internet, streaming tv, private beach, protected marina, grilling facilities, cooking facilities, coconut grove, salt water pool, theatre and much more.

Copyright © 2025 Lobster Cay · Privacy Policy · Site Design by Delos Incorporated